Plan for 8ft statue of ‘lesbian’ pirates at Devon beauty spot notorious for smuggling triggers uproar as critics say a ‘fisherman’s wife’ would be more appropriate
- Statue of pirates Anne Bonny and Mary Read is proposed at Burgh Island, Devon
- Locals have argued tributes to the pilchard industry would be more appropriate
- Other residents suggested a statue of a fisherman’s wife would be more fitting
- Bigbury Parish Council had 13 objections and voted unanimously against statue
- Anne Bonny and Mary Read were infamous pirates hanged in the Caribbean
Plans for a statue of two real-life female Pirates Of The Caribbean have caused outrage in a seaside community over claims they are ‘totally inappropriate’ and would ‘glamorise’ crime.
The concrete sculpture of 18th Century pirates Anne Bonny and Mary Read has been proposed at a beauty spot on Burgh Island in Devon.
The bloodthirsty pair were among the most notorious pirates as they wreaked havoc throughout the Caribbean during the golden age of piracy, which lasted from the mid-17th century to the 1720s.
Some historians claim the two became lesbian lovers while others suggest they formed a three-way relationship with Anne’s husband, the English pirate captain Jack Rackham – more commonly known as Calico Jack.
But critics argue the monument would be a ‘blot on the landscape’, and suggested a tribute to the local pilchard industry or a fisherman’s wife would be more appropriate.
One local described the statue as a, ‘very patriarchal view of two skinny women with holes cut out.’
The concrete sculpture of 18th Century pirates Anne Bonny and Mary Read has been proposed at a beauty spot on Burgh Island in Devon
Left Mary Read and right, Anne Bonny. The pair disguised themselves as men as they wreaked havoc on the high seas
Anne Bonny, John ‘Calico Jack’ Rackam and Mary Read: Some historians claim the two became lesbian lovers while others suggest they formed a three-way relationship with Anne’s husband, the English pirate captain Jack Rackham – more commonly known as Calico Jack
The swashbuckling women who wreaked havoc and terror on the high seas
Anne Bonny: Bonny was born in Ireland around 1700, the illegitimate daughter of wealthy lawyer, William Cormac, and his housemaid.
To keep his daughter close without arousing his wife’s suspicion, Cormac had her dressed as a boy and took her into his household as a lawyer’s clerk.
But when the ruse was uncovered Cormac, his mistress and daughter emigrated to Carolina, where he bought a plantation.
Anne later eloped with penniless sailor and part-time pirate, James Bonny.
The pair sought fortune among the Caribbean islands, and ended up on the island of New Providence in the Bahamas, a well-known pirate haunt.
It was there that Anne came across Captain Jack Rackham – aka, Calico Jack.
He was the pirate who came up with the Jolly Roger, the black flag with a skull and crossbones.
When the relationship between Anne and Rackam became known, Rogers had her flogged for adultery.
For several months, they sailed around the Caribbean on board her lover’s ship, the Vanity.
At some stage, she became pregnant with Rackam’s child. She went to Cuba to give birth, but the baby died or she abandoned.
Anne later took fancy to another sailor on their ship.
She later discovered that the sailor was a woman, Mary Read.
Mary Read: Read was born in England around 1690 and brought up by her widowed mother as a boy, in order to claim maintenance from her mother-in-law, who would not have paid up for a girl.
As a teenager, Mary joined the Army and fought for years in Holland without any of her fellow soldiers suspecting her identity.
She married a fellow trooper who died when the campaign was over.
Restless and penniless, she donned men’s clothing and boarded a ship bound for the West Indies.
Her ship was captured by Rackam’s and, together with many of her shipmates, she joined his crew.
The concrete statues were designed to celebrate the pair for breaking gender boundaries during the 18th century.
But a planning application to install the work on Burgh Island off the coast of Devon has been met with hostility from locals.
The strength of opposition saw the proposal rejected by Bigbury Parish Council on Monday.
One objector said it was a negative portrayal of woman and was celebrating a ‘couple of violent criminals who contributed nothing to the local heritage.’
Another said pirates were ‘not like Robin Hood or the Pirates of the Caribbean films’ but were ‘brutal, cruel and destructive.’
The statue created by artist Amanda Cotton was proposed by London-based marketing agency The Producers.
Island owner Giles Fuchs said he thought the 8.2ft tall statue on the island’s rocky shoreline, was a ‘brilliant idea.’
But objector Michele Knight-Waite said: ‘Burgh Island is an iconic beautiful natural space. I love walking and looking at it and imagining its history.
‘I am also a big fan of the tale of these two legendary pirates. However, I feel that this statue will detract from the historic site.
‘It brings nothing of value and indeed takes away the original historic view of the island. I strongly object as I feel it will impact the environment. It is totally inappropriate.
‘On top of that, the statue itself does not depict the energy of the two female pirates in anyway, who dressed as men and were powerful sailors.
‘The statue seems to be a very patriarchal view of two skinny women with holes cut out, I really don’t get it.
‘How is this in the spirit of the actual women? It isn’t. It will be a blot on the landscape. It reminds me of those 70’s statues.
‘It does not reflect the spirit of the pirates either.
‘Please do not place this on such a beautiful island.’
The statue would have found more support if it had been linked to the former pilchard fishing industry in the area, councillor Cathy Case said.
‘I’m not convinced it’s the right thing for the island,’ she added.
Councillor Sharon Smith agreed, adding: ‘It would be better to have a fisherman’s wife looking out to sea.
‘It does not belong in this area.’
Local Jan Davies added: ‘I’m a supporter of increasing the number of statues/art works of women but if anyone should be celebrated in this area it’s the generations of hard-working fishing and farming families rather than a couple of violent criminals who contributed nothing to the local heritage.’
Plans submitted by the agency in London show the proposed location on the island
Sculptor Amanda Cotton designed the statue, which will look out across the water
The concrete statues were designed to celebrate the pair, depicted here, for breaking gender boundaries during the 18th century
The island cut off by the tide, Agatha Christie and a haunted inn: The history of Burgh Island
Burgh Island is located directly opposite Bigbury-on-Sea beach and accessible at low tide by a strip of sand.
High tide completely covers the sand, leaving a ride on a sea tractor as the only means of access.
Agatha Christie made Burgh Island her second home and it serves as the setting for her novels ‘And Then There Were None’ and the Poirot mystery, ‘Evil Under The Sun’.
The island also boasts one the England’s oldest pubs, The Pilchard Inn.
Built in 1336, the Inn first served the fishermen who lived on the Island and mainland shores; then the smugglers and wreckers who lured ships onto the Western rocks.
The pub is said to be haunted by the ghost of the 19th-century smuggler Tom Crocker, a Burgh Island resident who was shot dead on the pub doorstep.
Source: Burgh Island
Gilbert Snook said: ‘I have to say I am astonished that such a proposal has got this far when statues of people who have done good in the country but at the time benefited from the system of slavering are being removed.
‘I’m sorry but pirates were not like Robin hood or the Pirates of the Caribbean films. They were brutal, cruel and destructive.
‘It’s a pity that this sculpture has been given this link to pirates since otherwise it would have been an interesting addition to the Island.’
Sculptor Amanda Cotton said Burgh Island was an obvious choice and a perfect home for the statue.
Little was known about Mary and Anne so the statue would ‘bring that rich history to the island’ and be a ‘visual reminder of the hidden voices of women’.
‘I wanted to make it sure it complemented the surroundings rather than took away from it,’ she said.
She added: ‘The sculpture’s design is a metaphor for Bonny and Read’s personality, Fire and Earth. Individually they are strong independent women but when Anne (Fire) and Mary (Earth) combine they are dangerously unstoppable.
‘The marine concrete the sculpture is made of will, over time, create a habitable environment for the surrounding wildlife, whilst being cast into the natural rock so that the two figures truly become one with their environment.’
Historian Professor Kate Williams, an expert in pirate history, said: ‘Mary Read and Anne Bonny were two of the most famed pirates in the eighteenth century, yet there is little said about them in our history books.
‘They broke gender boundaries and stunned people at the time. It’s imperative that we continue to unearth the hidden voices, histories of many women and LGBTQ+ persons.’
The statue was previewed at Execution Docks in London at the end of last year and was set to be transferred to its permanent home from early 2021 on Burgh Island
Plans for the statue: The marine concrete will provide a habitable environment for wildlife
The application from the design agency states: ‘We know little about Anne, born in Ireland 1697, and Mary, born in England 1685, as their story was largely overlooked by male historians.
‘As the old sailor’s adage goes, a woman on board invites bad luck, a superstition that turned out to be true for the enemies of notorious pirates Anne Bonny and Mary Read.
‘As quick to draw their cutlasses as they were to fall in love, Anne and Mary sailed the Caribbean leaving a trail of looted treasure, outfoxed law enforcement, and treacherous ex-lovers in their wake.
‘Born hundreds of miles apart, both Anne and Mary were disguised as boys in their childhoods to escape poverty, propriety and disgrace, only to find freedom on the high seas.
‘When Mary and Anne’s worlds collide a love affair between the two ensues and adventure beckons.
‘Ultimately it is a story about the determination to live fully and freely without the limitation of gender, class or society – a life without restraint.’
The statue was previewed at Execution Docks in London at the end of last year and was set to be transferred to its permanent home from early 2021 on Burgh Island.
A final decision will be made by South Hams District Council at a later date.
The REAL Pirates of the Caribbean: How an heiress and the widow became fearless and blood-thirsty cutlass-wielding pirates who would exposed their breasts to their dying victims
Pirates Anne Bonny and Mary Read, who were captured in 1720. They were a part of pirateer Calico Jack Rackam’s crew which terrorised the seas in the early 18th century, and they developed a reputation as a fearsome duo that commanded respect. They were both eventually sentenced to hanging for their piracy, but both escaped the feat after ‘pleading the belly’ – a rule in English law at the time that saw pregnant women receive a stay of execution until they gave birth. Neither were ever executed
Aside from such bloodthirsty captains as Captain Blackbeard and ‘Black’ Bart Roberts, the two most famous pirates from the golden age of piracy — which lasted from the mid-17th century to the 1720s — were the two female members of Calico Jack’s crew: Anne Bonny and Mary Read.
They were notorious throughout the Caribbean. Indeed, when Woodes Rogers, the governor of the Bahamas and a former privateer and pirate-hunter, issued a notice in the Boston Gazette on September 1720 calling for the arrest of Calico Jack’s crew, he named the two women as being guilty of stealing a 12-ton sloop named the William from Nassau harbour and numerous other acts of piracy.
Rogers was determined to stamp out piracy and showed no mercy to any pirate — male or female.
After their capture, Calico Jack and the male members of his crew were put on trial on November 16 in Jamaica. All were found guilty and hanged over the next two days.
The trial that the public had been waiting for — that of the two female pirates — was held ten days later.
Everyone was intrigued to discover how two women, one an heiress, the other a widow, had ended up on board Calico Jack’s ship, dressed as men, wielding cutlasses and pistols and terrorising sailors and passengers as they relieved them of their possessions and ships. Details of their early lives are hazy, but extraordinarily it seems they were raised as boys.
The pirate Mary Read (left), having killed a fellow pirate in a duel, exposes her breast to the dying man to show that he was killed by a woman. Anne Bonny is depicted on the right wearing the outfit of a European sailor from the period between 1713 and 1726. Bonny is believed to have been the Irish illegitimate daughter of a lawyer and a maid. Her exact end is unknown, with no record of her death or imprisonment. Historians she may have returned to live with her father in the US
The pirate Mary Read wielding a sword with an axe attached to her waist. Both Read and Bonny earned a reputation as fearsome fighters under the command of the pirate ‘Calico Jack’ Rackham (depicted right). The pair were part of his crew which terrorised the seas in the early 18th century. Rackham’s ship was invaded by a ‘pirate hunter’ on a day that saw the women’s bravery heralded. While his crew fled below deck, the women were the only two to fight by his side
Anne Bonny was born in Ireland around 1700 and was the illegitimate daughter of a wealthy lawyer, William Cormac, and his housemaid. To keep his daughter close without arousing his wife’s suspicion, Cormac had her dressed as a boy and took her into his household as a lawyer’s clerk.
But the ruse was uncovered and Cormac, his mistress and daughter emigrated to Carolina, where he bought a plantation.
Anne remained a tomboy, hot-headed and strong. When a man tried to force himself on her, she is said to have beaten him so badly that he was bedridden. As a wealthy heiress, her father expected Anne to marry well. But instead, his headstrong daughter eloped with penniless sailor and part-time pirate James Bonny.
A furious Cormac disinherited her, so Anne and James decided to seek their fortune among the Caribbean islands, where sugar and cotton had made many men wealthy. Ships laden with goods from the colonies provided rich pickings for pirates.
They ended up on the island of New Providence in the Bahamas, a well-known pirate haunt. It was there, perhaps in a saloon, that Anne came across the dashing, charismatic Calico Jack. He was the pirate who came up with the Jolly Roger, the black flag with a skull and crossbones.
He had made a career out of capturing small ships close to shore, but had renounced piracy, following a general pardon issued in 1719 by Woodes Rogers.
When the relationship between Anne and Rackam became known, Rogers had her flogged for adultery. He knew her husband well: James was said to be an informer on his former pirate friends, and it may have been at his behest that Anne was flogged.
If James thought it would make her see the error of her ways, he was mistaken. She refused to return to him and eloped to sea with Rackam, who immediately resumed piracy.
For several months, they sailed around the Caribbean, plundering ships that came their way. Most of Rackam’s crew had no idea Anne was a woman: she dressed, drank, cursed and fought like a man.
At some stage, she became pregnant with Rackam’s child. She went to Cuba to give birth, but the baby died or she abandoned it because she was soon back on board her lover’s ship, the Vanity.
Arguably the most notorious pirate of the age was Blackbeard (pictured), whose appearance was similar to Johnny Depp’s character Jack Sparrow in Pirates of the Caribbean. At his peak, Blackbeard, who plagued shipping lanes off North America and throughout the Caribbean, had two sloops and 150 men under his command. He is also known as either Edward Teach or Edward Thatch and is believed to have been born in Bristol in 1680
The severed head of the pirate ‘Blackbeard’, displayed on the boat of Lieutenant Maynard who defeated him with his crew. Robert Maynard was a lieutenant and later captain in the Royal Navy, he defeated Blackbeard the pirate’s final battle. It was he who suspended Blackbeard’s head from the bowsprit of his sloop so that the death reward could be collected. Teach’s corpse was thrown into the inlet and Maynard later noted that it had been shot five times and cut about twenty
While other pirates were notorious for their cruelty, chopping off fingers to steal rings, hacking their victims to death with machetes, and burning or disembowelling them alive, Rackam was gentlemanly. He often allowed the passengers on the ships he captured a choice: join the pirate crew or go free. He even returned one ship to its owner, once he had finished looting it.
On one occasion, the Vanity caught up with an armed vessel commissioned to hunt down pirates. When Rackam’s crew overpowered it, many of the men on board, some of whom were former pirates, agreed to join his crew.
Among them was a handsome sailor to whom Anne took an immediate fancy. Despite her relationship with Rackam, she pursued the youngster and at last managed to find some privacy and reveal her feelings and true gender.
To her amazement, she discovered that the sailor was a woman, too, named Mary Read.
Some historians claim the two became lesbian lovers. When a jealous Rackam burst into a cabin to find them in bed together, he threatened to kill his rival. But when he saw her breasts and realised she was a woman, his jealousy turned to delight.
Whether or not they entered into a menage a trois is impossible to know, but in any event Read was allowed to remain on board.
Mary’s story is as extraordinary as Anne’s. She was born in England around 1690 and brought up by her widowed mother as a boy, in order to claim maintenance from her mother-in-law, who would not have paid up for a girl.
As a teenager, Mary joined the Army and fought for years in Holland without any of her fellow soldiers suspecting her identity.
She fell in love with a fellow trooper with whom she shared a tent, and when the campaign was over, the two left the Army, married and opened an inn. But Mary’s husband died soon after.
Restless and penniless, she once more donned men’s clothing and boarded a ship bound for the West Indies.
There, she joined a pirate-hunting expedition, hoping to share in the prize money for any vessels they caught. Instead, her ship was captured by Rackam’s and, together with many of her shipmates, she joined his crew.
The published report of the trial of ‘Calico Jack’ Rackam, Mary Read and Anne Bonny, along with ten of their shipmates, which was held in Jamaica in November 1720. The report was published the next year by a Robert Baldwin. Rackham was not one of the most famous or more successful pirates but his story is well known because of his two female counterparts
Stede Bonnet, a wealthy land-owner in Barbados who turned to a life of crime in light of marital problems. He was captured and executed in late 1718, a year after becoming a pirate. He was dubbed the ‘gentleman’ pirate due to his ‘hapless’ nature
In August 1720, they stole a sloop from Nassau harbour, an audacious act that so infuriated the governor that he sent several ships to hunt them down.
For the next few weeks, they evaded capture, preying on fishing vessels, the two female pirates fighting boldly alongside the men.
It seems unlikely that eating, sleeping and working side by side, that the other pirates remained unaware of the presence of two women in their midst.
Indeed, according to a witness at their trial, their sex was obvious. Dorothy Thomas, a Jamaican fisherwoman captured by the pirates as she paddled her canoe off the coast, explained that the reason she knew they were women was ‘by the largeness of their breasts’.
She described how ‘each of them had a machete and pistol in their hands, and cursed and swore at the men, to murder [her]’ but the rest of the crew let her go.
Another witness attested that the two women wore men’s clothes when involved in a chase or attack — in which they always took an active part — but the rest of the time they dressed as women.
Both had furious tempers, ‘cursing and swearing much’, and fought like ‘hellcats’.
Neither woman had any illusions about the price they would pay for piracy if caught. Mary even told one of the sailors they had captured that the prospect of hanging was ‘no great hardship. For were it not for that every cowardly fellow would turn pirate and so infest the seas that men of courage must starve’.
Anne showed a similar lack of remorse. She was allowed to visit her lover, Calico Jack, in his cell hours before he was executed. If he had been expecting some tenderness, he was to be disappointed.
She told him she was sorry to see him there, but if he had fought like a man he need not to have been hanged like a dog.
Charles Vane (left), the leader of the ‘die-hard’ pirates of New Providence. He was captured and executed in 1721, hanged in a cage at the entrance to Jamaica harbour in a show trial wherein the authorities tried to make an example of him. Bartholomew Roberts (right), otherwise known as ‘Black Bart’ was among the most notorious pirates from pirateering’s heyday
A British single-masted sloop. Probably the most commonly encountered pirate vessel, shown in 1718. The golden age of piracy is considered to have lasted just over a decade, from 1713 to 1726
A 19th century engraving showing pirates enjoying a party or ‘banyan’ on a beach. A banyan is basically naval a custom that continues to evolve over the years. Pirates are pictured playing music on fiddles and drinking alcohol
He was duly executed and his body displayed in an iron cage hung from a gibbet on a small island near Port Royal, Jamaica, now known as Rackam’s Cay.
When it came to their trial ten days later, neither of the women called witnesses or offered any defence of their actions. They were found guilty and sentenced to death.
For all their bravado, perhaps they had not expected to be hanged, for it was only then that they begged the court for mercy with the words: ‘My lord, we plead our bellies.’
An examination proved they were, indeed, pregnant, whether by Calico Jack or by other members of his crew is uncertain (Mary is said to have taken another lover while on board his ship).
It was enough to save their necks: British law forbade the killing of an unborn child, so their sentences were stayed. Mary died some months later from a ‘violent fever’. The parish register records her burial on April 28, 1721.
It is not known what happened to Anne. Perhaps she returned to Carolina and settled down to a life of respectability on a plantation.
It is unlikely that she returned to the high seas, for by 1725 the golden age of piracy was over.
So damaging was the pirates’ impact on trade that the British government had ordered the Royal Navy to eliminate piracy. The pirates were hunted down and driven from their lairs, their leaders tried and hung.
The strategy worked. In 1720, there had been 2,000 pirates. By 1726, they numbered fewer than 200. But their notorious deeds and flamboyant behaviour secured them mythical status, their stories being told and retold in books, plays and film.
By Annabelle Venning for the Daily Mail
The execution of the ‘gentleman pirate’, Stede Bonnet at Charles Town in late 1718. Because of his background, when he was captured. he was still regarded as a ‘gentleman’ and therefore lodged in the private house of the local marshal before hanging
Routes taken by the pirate ‘Blackbeard’, probably the most fearsome of all. His route spanned the US and the Caribbean. Piracy can be traced back to Roman times, with the capture of Julius Caesar by Cilician pirates in 75BC, who held him for ransom
Source: Read Full Article